QUOTE (mrwallpaper @ Mon, 1 Feb 2010 - 17:13)

1) Was the legality of the sign ever clarified?
According to sharewatcher, his daughter
won on appeal to the High Court of Justiciary (Scottish High Court).
Unfortunately, he has provided scant details of the case; e.g. was the legality of the signs ever tested, or, e.g., was it because the JP decided that she hadn't proved that they weren't authorised (notwithstanding that she had
prima facie evidence of non compliance), i.e. a procedural error on the court's part?
Further, it appears to have been disposed of at some sort of
preliminary hearing, hence there might not be a judgement. She should still have something from the HCJ, though.
From that second post, it certainly appears that the legality of the signs themselves (in terms of compliance with the TSRGDs), was not an issue, otherwise there would be no need for another accused to go through all the hoops that he was suggesting in that post.